SCREENRANT VIDEO OF THE DAY Both television receiver adaptations ran for similar lengths excessively. Game of Thrones spanned a total of 8 seasons between 2011 and 2019, while The Expanse began in 2015 and will end in 2022 with season 6. Roles are reversed in the literary stakes – The Expanse ‘s final examination novel dropped in 2021, while George R.R. Martin’s The Winds of Winter is proving more elusive than a Game of Thrones episode that ‘s safe to watch with your grandparents.
Related : Why HBO Ignored George R.R. Martin ’ s design To Save Game Of Thrones
For all their parallels, however, Game of Thrones season 8 and The Expanse temper 6 are cursed with polar diametric problems. Both were backed into a corner by undesirable end points, but each picked a vastly different solution. immediately the two franchises could n’t be further apart. here ‘s why The sweep ‘s concluding season is the anti-Game of Thrones .
The Expanse & Game Of Thrones Both End Too Early
For six unharmed seasons, Game of Thrones maintained a brace canter – moving with ample pace, but still allowing plenty of room for George R.R. Martin’s hallmark elaborateness and compelling characterization. By the end of Game of Thrones season 6, however, David Benioff and D.B. Weiss were overtaking Martin ‘s ledger, and HBO was acute to bring an ending into sight. Though “ not wanting the usher to outstay its welcome ” remains Benioff and Weiss ‘ official reason, episode budgets were soaring and cast members had begun capitalizing on their fresh found fame by seizing wide opportunities. Either way, the decision was taken to end Game of Thrones with season 8 .
In hindsight, this was a spectacularly poor move. Benioff and Weiss on the spur of the moment found themselves with a spaghetti articulation of plat threads to tie up, and merely a handful of episodes in which to do so. game of Thrones season 8 accelerated abruptly, and that rush to the finish resulted in bungled characters, absurd narrative dead-ends, and a distinctly dissatisfy consultation .
George R.R. Martin has since gone on phonograph record expressing regret that Game of Thrones ended with season 8, admitting his floor needed a few more runs to wrap up properly. surely, more episodes could ‘ve alleviated the most blazing problems with Games of Thrones ‘ ending, and even if the address remained unchanged, those extra seasons could ‘ve built towards Benioff and Weiss ‘ intend resolving power more naturally .
Related : Marco ’ s Asteroids Create A Worse Problem For Earth In Expanse Season 6
The Expanse Season 6 Does The Opposite To Game Of Thrones Season 8
Mirroring Game of Thrones ‘ aura years, The Expanse avoided any temptation to steam ahead, with seasons 1-5 adapting approximately one of James S.A. Corey ‘s books per season. Though more slow-burning than the misadventures of the Starks and Lannisters, The Expanse ‘s measure tempo allowed for the like supreme world-building and affectional character insight that had audiences so profoundly invested in the comings and goings of Westeros. Alas, not all parallels are convinced. Just as HBO left Games of Thrones with a deplorably short sum of episodes to resolve the bumper catalogue of character bow and storylines remaining, Amazon gave The Expanse 6 episodes to adapt a full of 4 relatively chunky books .
While both shows were consider the lapp regretful hand, The Expanse ‘s reaction could n’t be far removed from its counterpart in the fantasy section. Game of Thrones treated HBO ‘s 8-season mandate as a personal challenge to tie off every lingering thread before the curtain fell – no matter how messily. The Expanse, on the other hand, is maintaining its plan course .
With so much material hush to adapt, audiences might ‘ve expected The Expanse season 6 to kick up a few gears. possibly book 6 ‘s free Navy conflict would cover episodes 1-3, then the Laconia and Dark Gods fabric from later volumes gets lumped together for a three-part stopping point. rather, The Expanse season 6 ‘s pacing has scantily tickled the gasoline hard than season 5. Based on the episodes aired sol army for the liberation of rwanda, The Expanse temper 6 is honoring its “ one book per temper ” format and focusing squarely on adapting sixth fresh, Babylon ‘s Ashes. Viewers possibly besides anticipated The Expanse would drop its longer-term narratives, abandoning the Laconia and Dark Gods frame-up in party favor of properly ending the Marco Inaros saga. once again, that has n’t been the case. The Expanse season 6 is continuing to drop teases for both storylines as if 4 seasons remain, rather than 4 episodes .
Why The Expanse’s Approach Is Better Than Game Of Thrones Season 8
Both were maneuvered into finales sooner than they should ‘ve, but while Game of Thrones responded by haphazard crashing toward a resolving power, logic be damned, The Expanse is refusing to be creatively influenced by Amazon ‘s time skeleton. Neither scenario is precisely ideal ( why would The Expanse fishing gear one season at a clock unless intending to finally adapt all nine ? ), but on balance, The Expanse season 6 ‘s strategy is smarter.
Related : The area : Why Naomi Really Hates Peaches In Season 6
reaction to Game of Thrones season 8 proved predominantly veto, and the show has since become synonymous with disappointing television endings. There ‘s a bitter sarcasm in how Game of Thrones hurriedly resolves as many plot points as possible, apparently believing some resolution is better than no resolution at all. But the proofread is in Hot Pie ‘s pudding, and the intensity of veto palpate suggests Game of Thrones would ‘ve been better off maintaining its narrative integrity … even if that meant leaving some long-reaching tales unfinished .
The Expanse deftly avoids Games of Thrones ‘ frenzied tempo and sum absence of cohesion, but faces the complete diametric problem – will audiences be left defeated when those Laconia and Dark Gods teases are just left suspension, with neither coming to the fore, and nothing to explain why they have n’t ? Is exciting buildup with no payoff better than poor buildup with equally poor wages ?
Given the current landscape of streaming, very possibly. The Expanse is surely taking a gamble leaving indeed much unsaid this close to its final episode, but at least the door is left loose for a future lengthiness. possibly another service buys the property, or renewed interest leads to a sequel years down the telephone line. The Expanse then has the exemption to pick up where it left off, adapting books 7, 8 and 9 faithfully, with board to breathe. Game of Thrones, meanwhile, is what it is .
true, The Expanse possesses the advantage of a 30-year book time jump, which would allow any sequel to cast wholly fresh actors. But even if this was n’t the case, The Expanse season 6 is prioritizing quality storytelling over complete storytelling, trusting the future will finish what it started. That ‘s better than Game of Thrones tarnishing an integral body of work with one measly concluding season. At the identical least, viewers will be angry at the network for pulling the plug early on, preferably than the writers for delivering an anticlimactic closing chapter .
More : Expanse ’ s Final Villain Tease Breaks The Books ’ Time Jump
The Expanse season 6 airs every Friday on Amazon Prime .
Legacies Cancelled At CW Ending Vampire Diaries Franchise’s 13-Year Run
About The Author
( 3741 Articles Published )
Craig first began contributing to Screen Rant in 2016, respective years after graduating college, and has been ranting ever since, by and large to himself in a darken room. Having previously written for assorted sports and music outlets, Craig ‘s interest soon turned to television receiver and film, where a steadily upbringing of science fiction and comic books ultimately came into its own. Craig has previously been published on sites such as Den of Geek, and after many coffee-drenched hours hunched over a laptop, part-time evening exercise finally turned into a full-time career covering everything from the zombi apocalypse to the Starship Enterprise via the TARDIS. Since joining the Screen Rant flock, Craig has been involved in breaking news stories and mildly controversial ranking lists, but now works predominantly as a features writer. Jim Carrey is Craig ’ s top acting pick and favorite topics include superheroes, zanzibar copal and the unrecognized flair of the High School Musical trilogy .
More From Craig Elvy